Best Airbnb Host Insurance Providers Compared (2026)

• Proper Insurance offers the most comprehensive commercial policy that fully replaces your homeowner's insurance.
• Safely and Slice provide flexible, per-booking insurance ideal for hosts who want tech-integrated solutions or only rent part-time.
• Your homeowner's insurance policy and Airbnb's AirCover are not sufficient protection for your rental business.
• Always verify your city’s requirements, as places like Austin or San Francisco have specific insurance mandates for short-term rentals.

You've dialed in your listing, perfected your guest messaging, and maybe even started seeing five-star reviews roll in. But you have a nagging feeling. What happens if something truly goes wrong? Not a broken wine glass, but a serious injury on your property or a fire that puts you out of business for months. You assume Airbnb's AirCover has you, well, covered. Unfortunately, that's a dangerous assumption that could cost you everything. AirCover is not insurance, and your standard homeowner's policy almost certainly excludes business activity. You're left in a massive coverage gap, and it's time to fix it.

• Airbnb’s AirCover is a host protection program, not a substitute for a real insurance policy. It has numerous gaps and the claims process is controlled entirely by Airbnb.
• Your standard homeowner's or landlord policy likely contains a 'business exclusion' clause that voids coverage for short-term rental activity.
• True short term rental insurance is a commercial policy designed to cover the unique risks of hosting, including liability, property damage, and loss of income.
• The best insurance for you depends on your location, rental frequency (full-time vs. part-time), and property type.
• On-demand, pay-per-night insurance can be a cost-effective solution for hosts who only rent their primary home occasionally.
• Proactive risk management, such as using guest screening tools and clear house rules, is your first line of defense against claims.

How We Evaluated These Insurance Providers

The world of vacation rental insurance can be confusing. To cut through the noise, we focused on providers that specifically cater to the US short-term rental market. We didn't rank based on sponsorships. Our evaluation is based on real-world factors that matter to hosts like you, from the type of coverage offered to the ease of making a claim when you need it most. We looked for companies that understand that hosting is a business, not a hobby.

• Coverage Type: Does it replace your homeowner's policy (commercial), supplement it (supplemental), or just add a small rider (endorsement)?
• Core Protections: Does the policy cover the big three: commercial general liability, damage to your buildings and contents, and loss of rental income?
• Pricing Model: Is it an annual policy paid upfront or monthly, or is it a flexible pay-per-booking model?
• STR-Specific Benefits: Does it cover unique hosting risks like bed bug infestations, squatters, or damage caused by guests?
• Claims Process: What is the provider's reputation for handling and paying out claims fairly and efficiently?
• Ease of Use: How simple is it to get a quote, purchase a policy, and manage your account?

Best Airbnb Host Insurance Providers: A Quick Comparison

Proper Insurance: Best All-in-One Commercial Policy

Proper Insurance is the name you'll hear most often in host communities, and for good reason. They offer a comprehensive commercial insurance policy written specifically for the short-term rental industry. This isn't an add-on or an endorsement; it's a primary policy designed to completely replace your existing homeowner's insurance. Underwritten by Lloyd's of London, it combines the coverage of a homeowner's policy (for your personal use), a landlord policy, and a business policy into one package. It covers your building, contents, business income, and commercial liability, providing the most robust protection on the market. If you are a full-time operator and your property's main purpose is as a short-term rental, this is the gold standard.

Try CheckinGuide free

Stop typing the same WiFi password 50 times a month.

CheckinGuide gives every guest a beautiful digital welcome guide so they stop messaging you the basics.

• Who it's for: Full-time hosts and property managers who want one comprehensive policy without any gaps.
• Headline Pricing: Typically starts around $1,800 - $3,500 per year, which is often 2-3x a standard homeowner's policy, but it replaces it entirely.
• Standout Strength: Unmatched comprehensive coverage. It includes protections for things many others don't, like bed bugs, squatters, and ordinance/law coverage.
• Honest Weakness: It can be overkill and too expensive for a host who only rents out their primary home for a few weekends a year. There is no pay-per-use option.

Safely: Best for Per-Booking Coverage & Guest Screening

Safely is more than just an insurance provider; it's a technology-driven trust and safety platform. They are a great fit for the modern host who wants protection integrated directly into their booking flow. Instead of a large annual policy, Safely charges a small fee per booking. For this, you get comprehensive guest screening and up to $1,000,000 in liability and property damage coverage. This approach supplements your existing homeowner's or landlord policy. It's designed to cover the specific risks of a guest stay, not the building itself from perils like fire or storms (your primary policy covers that). Their promise of quick payouts for small-to-medium damage claims is a major selling point for busy hosts.

• Who it's for: Hosts who want integrated technology, fast claims on smaller damages, and robust guest screening without committing to a full commercial policy.
• Headline Pricing: Starts around $8 per night, which includes guest screening and coverage.
• Standout Strength: The seamless integration of guest verification and insurance coverage. It encourages proactive risk management, which aligns perfectly with using tools like CheckinGuide's own guest verification service.
• Honest Weakness: It is not a replacement for your primary property insurance. You still need a homeowner's or landlord policy that allows short-term rental activity (a 'friendly' carrier).

Slice: Best for On-Demand, Part-Time Hosts

Slice pioneered the concept of on-demand, pay-per-use vacation rental insurance. If you only rent your home when you're on vacation or for a few popular weekends in your city like SXSW in Austin or a big game in Nashville, Slice is a perfect fit. The entire process is managed through a simple app. You turn coverage on when you need it and off when you don't. You only pay for the nights a guest is staying. The policy provides commercial liability protection, full replacement cost for your home and its contents, and even covers loss of income. It's a true commercial policy, but one you can access with incredible flexibility.

• Who it's for: The occasional host who rents out their primary residence and wants hassle-free, on-demand coverage without an annual commitment.
• Headline Pricing: Typically between $7 - $12 per night, depending on your property's value and location.
• Standout Strength: Unbeatable flexibility. The ability to switch coverage on and off via an app empowers hosts to only pay for exactly what they use.
• Honest Weakness: For full-time hosts, the per-night cost can add up quickly and become more expensive than a comprehensive annual policy from a provider like Proper.

CBIZ Vacation Rental Insurance: Best for Multi-Property Portfolios

CBIZ is a large, established insurance broker that has been offering specialized vacation rental insurance for years. They are an excellent choice for professional hosts or small property managers who have a portfolio of properties and need a more customized insurance solution. Their policy is a commercial package that includes general liability and business property coverage. Because they are a broker, they can work with you to tailor a program that fits your specific collection of rentals, which might include different types of homes in various locations like Scottsdale and Miami. The process may feel more traditional than newer tech platforms, but their deep experience in the commercial insurance world is a significant asset.

• Who it's for: Professional hosts and small property managers with multiple properties who need a tailored insurance program.
• Headline Pricing: Annual policies often start around $1,000 but scale with the size and value of your portfolio.
• Standout Strength: Expertise in handling complex, multi-property portfolios and providing customized commercial insurance solutions.
• Honest Weakness: The process can be less automated and more 'old-school' than tech-first companies like Slice or Safely. Getting a quote often requires speaking with an agent.

Foremost (Farmers): Best Landlord Policy Adapted for STRs

Built into CheckinGuide

Take a £200 security deposit on your next booking in 30 seconds.

Pre-authorise deposits, verify guest ID, and capture e-signatures, all from one branded guest portal.

For hosts who feel more comfortable with a household name, Foremost, a part of the Farmers Insurance Group, is a solid option. They offer a landlord insurance policy that can be adapted to cover short-term rentals. This isn't a purpose-built STR policy in the same way Proper's is, but it's a significant step up from a standard homeowner's policy. It provides liability protection and property damage coverage. If you already have your auto or primary home insurance with Farmers, you may be able to get a bundling discount. It's a good middle-ground for hosts who want more than an endorsement but aren't ready to commit to a top-tier commercial policy.

• Who it's for: Hosts who prefer working with a large, well-known insurance brand and may have the opportunity to bundle policies.
• Headline Pricing: Highly variable, but can be competitive, especially with multi-policy discounts.
• Standout Strength: The trust and stability associated with a major national carrier like Farmers. The process will feel familiar to anyone who has bought standard insurance.
• Honest Weakness: The policy isn't as specialized for STRs as others. You'll need to carefully review the policy language to ensure it explicitly covers short-term rental activity and doesn't have restrictive clauses.

Allstate HostAdvantage: Best Endorsement for Existing Customers

If you're an existing Allstate customer and only host very occasionally, their HostAdvantage program is worth looking into. It is critical to understand what this is: an endorsement, not a standalone policy. It's a small rider that you add to your existing Allstate homeowner's policy. For a very low cost, it adds a sliver of protection, primarily for your personal property. For example, it might offer up to $10,000 per rental period to cover damage to your belongings. It's a simple, cheap way to get a little bit more peace of mind, but it does not provide the robust liability or property protection of a real commercial policy.

• Who it's for: Existing Allstate customers who host very infrequently and are primarily looking to cover theft or damage to their personal belongings.
• Headline Pricing: As low as $50 per year added to your existing policy.
• Standout Strength: Incredibly cheap and easy to add for current Allstate customers.
• Honest Weakness: The coverage is extremely limited. It is not a commercial liability policy and should not be considered adequate protection for anyone who relies on their rental income.

How to Choose the Right Short-Term Rental Insurance

Selecting the right insurance feels like a big decision, because it is. Your choice comes down to three main factors: your local regulations, your hosting frequency, and your personal tolerance for risk. Don't just pick the cheapest option. Start by understanding your legal obligations and then honestly assess how your property is being used. A cabin in Joshua Tree operated as a full-time rental business has vastly different needs than a spare room in Denver you rent for a few ski weekends.

Full-Time Business vs. Part-Time Gig

Free for your first guide

Verify your next guest's ID before they even arrive.

Stripe Identity and manual ID checks built in. Reject risky bookings before they ruin your stay.

If your property is primarily a short-term rental and a key source of your income, you need a full commercial policy. This is a non-negotiable business expense. A provider like Proper Insurance or a tailored package from CBIZ is your best bet. It fully protects your asset, liability, and income stream. If you only host occasionally in your primary residence, the math changes. A full commercial policy might be too costly. Here, the flexibility of an on-demand provider like Slice or a supplemental policy from Safely makes much more financial sense.

Understanding Policy Types: A Quick Breakdown

Remember, insurance is just one piece of the puzzle. Managing your risk also involves proactive measures like collecting a security deposit. Many hosts are now exploring more modern, guest-friendly options, which we cover in detail in our guide to security deposit alternatives for Airbnb.

Where CheckinGuide Fits Into Your Risk Strategy

Think of your risk management in two parts: proactive prevention and reactive protection. Your insurance policy is the reactive part—it's there for when a disaster happens. Tools like CheckinGuide are the proactive part—they help prevent that disaster from ever occurring. By using a robust guest verification system to confirm identities before arrival, you deter bad actors from the start. By providing a beautiful digital welcome guide, you clearly set rules and expectations, reducing the chance of accidental damage. And by managing security deposits and offering thoughtful upsells, you professionalize your operation and create a better guest relationship. You hope to never use your insurance, and a solid pre-arrival process makes that more likely. See how it all works with a quick demo.

Frequently asked questions

Bottom line: relying on Airbnb AirCover and your homeowner's policy is a risky gamble that successful hosts don't take. The right short term rental insurance isn't just another expense; it's a critical investment in protecting your asset, your income, and your peace of mind. Analyze your specific hosting frequency and local laws, compare quotes from a few of these top providers, and get the proper coverage in place before you welcome your next guest. It's the foundation of a sustainable and professional rental business.

Try CheckinGuide

Turn this into a 5-star check-in in under 10 minutes.

CheckinGuide gives every guest a beautiful digital welcome guide, ID verification, security deposits and upsells. Set it up once and watch your reviews and revenue climb.

• Free forever for your first guide
• No app for guests to download
• ID checks and deposits built in
• Cuts repetitive guest questions by 80%